Annoyances.org
Home » Windows Vista Discussion Forum » Message 1269367868 Search | Help | Home
  
Tip: Run a free scan for common Windows errors ad

re: Defragmentation
Tuesday, March 23, 2010 at 11:11 am
Windows Vista Annoyances Discussion Forum
Posted by Keith Stanier (1651 messages posted)


Gio7707 wrote:
|WIndows vista SP2, is it necessary/wise to do a defragmentation,or just a
|waste of time ?? 

Well Vistas defrag is worse than WinXP's you can't see nothing happening with Vista. 
On WinXP you only see coloured lines with hardly any movement.

Now hard drives are like libraries that store books/files. As books are taken out 
on loan there are spaces on the shelves as new books come in and that are larger 
than the spaces available they go on their own new shelf. The same goes for the files 
on the drive. Software is installed and file are added. Software is uninstalled and 
files are deleted so the drive becomes like a cullender with loads of holes.

To me a defragger should work like the original DOS and Win9x/ME systems. They should 
remove all spaces by moving all files to the front of the drive.

Now defrag has been out for years I know it was used in DOS 6.0 it may have been 
used in DOS 5.0. As it says its a DOS defragger with did the job properly. With Windows 
3.1 there was no defragger as it could still be done under DOS. With Win9x/ME that 
was a very good defragger because it moved all files up to the front of the drive 
and I wish the WinNT systems would work the same.

What I would recommend is
Defraggler 1.17.172
Its a lot more visual what is happening and its free.

Even after running Defraggler you will see a load of spaces on the drive this must 
be down to how a NTFS system works.

Now it will depend on how often you need to defrag by the files on your system, how 
often they change in size. If you download loads of movies they all take up space. 
After you have watched the movie you may save them to an external hard drive as a 
backup then they will be deleted of the main drive. I download lots of large files 
and I use them and save them to an external drive then delete so these spaces come 
in various sizes. I normally defrag with defraggler every couple of weeks. Defragging 
may depending on how bad the file system is speed up the operation of programs.

Give Defraggler a go you have nothing to loose. Its made by the same company Piriform 
that makes CCleaner, Recuva and Speccy and those are all free. They also have their 
own forum is you have any problems or questions about any of there products.

Piriform Forum I've been 
on there for years.



Written in response to:
Defragmentation (Gio7707: Sunday, March 21, 2010 at 8:53 pm)

Responses to this message:
*re: Defragmentation (MartinM: Tuesday, March 23, 2010 at 4:29 pm)

All messages in this thread [show all]
-Defragmentation (Gio7707: Sun, Mar 21, 2010, 8:53 pm)
-re: Defragmentation (jbmcmillan: Mon, Mar 22, 2010, 4:33 am)
*re: Defragmentation (Gio7707: Mon, Mar 22, 2010, 11:09 am)
*re: Defragmentation (Adam Bradley: Mon, Mar 22, 2010, 9:29 am)
-re: Defragmentation (Keith Stanier: Tue, Mar 23, 2010, 11:11 am)
*re: Defragmentation (MartinM: Tue, Mar 23, 2010, 4:29 pm)
Return to the Windows Vista Discussion Forum


All content at Annoyances.org is Copyright ©1995-2012 Creative Elementtm All rights reserved.
Please do not plagiarize; redistributing these pages without permission is strictly prohibited.